Categories
Impact Wrench

Electric Impact Wrench or Air — Which Is Better?

Impact wrenches are mainly used in automotive shops to loosen tight wheel nuts. These are usually pneumatic impact wrenches that work with compressed air. A compressed air motor drives the working spindle either via a mechanical impact device or via an oil circulation device. On the other hand, there are also impact wrenches with an electric function. Here, the working spindle is driven by an electric motor via a striking mechanism. A special feature is that there are also models that are operated with the help of a rechargeable battery.

Electric Impact vs Air

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Compressed Air Impact Wrench

ir-impact-wrench-300x248

There are also air impact wrenches for home use, which are smaller and can be purchased for a bargain. A compressed air impact wrench requires compressed air, which is usually generated by an air compressor. Thus, it is often necessary to purchase a more expensive compressor or purchase a special torque wrench in order to be able to use the impact wrench effectively. It is also advantageous that there is no maximum duty cycle and thus hours long work is guaranteed.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Electric Impact Wrench

Electric impact wrenches can be found mainly in households, as they can be used very well. However, these are often not satisfactory from the performance and are not suitable, for example, for industrial automotive use. The area of application of these electric impact wrenches is thus relatively small.

However, there are also large models, which, depending on the design, even achieve a higher performance than air impact wrenches. However, these are very expensive and can therefore be found mainly in workshops.

2767-245x300

In addition, there are also impact wrenches that work with a rechargeable battery. They are portable and handy, I keep one in the trunk of my car. Depending on the type of model, these can also perform very well. The greatest advantage of such a device is its mobility, because the cordless impact wrench does not need a connection and is therefore not dependent on a fixed location.

Conclusion

Each type of impact wrench has its advantages and disadvantages. So you need to be aware of what use you have for the impact wrench. If you need it for smaller work, it is better to use an electric impact wrench because of the mobility and handiness. Compressed air impact wrenches, on the other hand, are more suitable for larger work in workshops. However, for heavy-duty work, such as the loosening of wheel nuts, a model with sufficient power is always required, whether compressed air or electric impact wrench.

Categories
Impact Wrench

Porter Cable PCE211 1/2″ 7.5 Amp Impact Wrench

Below you’ll find a review on the Porter Cable PCE211 Impact Wrench. This impact wrench won our award for best budget impact wrench in our article on the best impact wrenches.

Overview

  • 5 Amp Motor
  • 450-ft-lbs torque
  • 2200rpm
  • 2700 bpm
  • 1/2″ hog ring anvil

Porter Cable PCE211 1/2″ 7.5 Amp Impact Wrench Review

porter-cable-impact-wrench-300x300

Worked pretty well to get nuts off quickly, but was struggling to get some of the more rusty lug nuts loose. So this wrench is not quite in the same range as other impact wrenches, but it’ll get the job done.

Will make your work quicker, that’s for sure. But we do not see it in the same range of power torque that you would get from an air impact wrench. Plus this drill is slightly heavier than other impact wrenches. It’s a corded tool, so it isn’t quite as convenient as the impacts we reviewed above, but for the price, it’s an excellent overall wrench.

Excellent for removing lug nuts off with some effort, so not the best pick, however, we got it for a great deal! This wrench is a bit on the heavy side, but it’ll get your regular nuts in a few seconds.

If you’re looking for something on the inexpensive side, then this is a good pick for the best budget impact wrench.

Additional Pictures

porter-cable-pce211-side-678x381

F/R Switch

Further Reading

Categories
Impact Wrench

DeWALT DCF899HB Impact Wrench

Find our review of the DeWALT DCF899HB Impact Wrench below.

Overview

611kFbNYzbL

  • Compact
  • Up to 700 ft-lbs of max torque
  • Up to 1200 ft-lbs of max breakaway torque
  • Multi-speed motor: 400rpm, 1200rpm, 1900rpm
  • 1/2″ Anvil with hog ring or detent pin
  • LED light

DeWALT DCF899HB Review

The DeWALT DCF889HB is a beast in the shop. Takes nuts with no effort & the supplied 5 ah 20v battery is excellent for all day work. Such a convenient tool when compared to an air powered impact. It gives a very similar response to pneumatic air guns. DeWALT gives real torque in a compact cordless tool. Furthermore, it’s light, but not too light. It’s a durable tool, and you won’t struggle taking off any lug nuts with this thing. Comes with multiple power settings, which is useful for tightening bolts of different kinds. Compares with some of the best impact wrenches on the market today.

Categories
Impact Wrench

Makita XWT08Z Impact Wrench

Below you will find our review on the Makita XWT08Z Impact Wrench

Overview

71CK+yUKUzL._AC_SL1500_

  • 740 ft lbs fastening torque
  • 1180 ft lbs break-away torque
  • Heavy and Bulky
  • Good Battery Life
  • Good Torque

Makita XWT08Z Review

We found this drill was much bigger in comparison to other impact wrenches in the market. However, it does excel at performance. This cordless brushless impact from Makita gives 740 ft lbs of fastening torque and 1180 ft lbs of break-away torque. Works great on those rusted and frozen lug nuts, comparable power to an IR air impact. No struggles with any fasteners. It’s a heavy, durable impact wrench with good battery life and torque. We give it 4 stars.

Categories
Impact Wrench

Best Impact Wrench 2019 — Impact Wrench Reviews

There are a lot of different models and brands of impact wrenches in the market today, so which is the best? You may have looked at Amazon for deals already, but you might be wondering with all the choices, how do you choose the best impact wrench! Don’t worry, in this article, we will discuss just that.

We found that the best impact wrench is the Milwaukee 2767-20 and we will tell you why below. First, let’s compare all of the other options so that you can pick the right impact wrench for you.

Here’s a table with our favorite impact wrenches and their specs.

Table of Contents

Best Impact Wrench

Name Type Torque Weight
Milwaukee M18 FUEL Impact Wrench Cordless 1400 ft lbs 5.9 pounds
DeWalt DCF899HB Impact Wrench Cordless 1200 ft lbs 5.8 pounds
Ingersoll Rand 2235 Ti Max Air Powered 1350 ft lbs 4.6 pounds

Here is a list of the best impact wrench, so you can compare options and choose the best one for you.

Milwaukee 2767-20 1/2″ Impact Wrench M18 with Friction Ring

2767-1-245x300

Let’s start with this excellent Milwaukee 1/2 impact. Cordless and battery operated — Milwaukee sets the bar high for this one. This is our top pick for impact wrench. It combines the right tool and the right price. It has a lot of torque in reverse, quite surprised with this and more power than an air impact wrench, definitely worth the price. Air tools will struggle to keep up with this. This is going to be the last impact you’ll ever buy.

Seriously, there no nut this wrench couldn’t take, this Milwaukee impact truly is a monster. Features 1000 ft-lbs of fastening torque and 1400 ft-lbs of nut busting torque. It took off lug nuts an air impact couldn’t even budge.

Batteries last a good while and its fast on the recharge too. Everyone at my mechanics shop knows these are excellent impact wrench, to the point that they just buy it. It’s a reasonable price and a powerful cordless impact. Milwaukee cordless tools got it right with this high torque and robust tool. I must say though it has massive power, it works great, no more pneumatic impact gun. The protective overmold provides protection against corrosive materials. Plus, the tool fits in your hand nicely.

Milwaukee has taken the impact wrench and made it cordless and powerful this is an obvious pick for best impact wrench. This impact wrench is a beast. It really has power that far exceeds my old air impact, and vs. my old air impact, it can’t even compare. Works great to remove those rusty lug nuts. This is probably the best brushless impact gun I have ever owned, on par with the most high-end air impacts.

Great features, lots of torque, a really great product at an attractive and affordable price. The compact design makes it useful for being able to reach hard-to-reach places. No need for air powered impacts anymore.

>> Check Sale Price on Amazon <<

DeWALT DCF899HB Brushless 1/2″ Torque Impact

889hb-300x300

This is our favorite Dewalt in the market for a cordless brushless impact wrench. It has not let me down. This is another beast of an impact, and the 5 ah 20v battery is excellent.

A true powerhouse. If you are considering to get one of these to replace your air impact gun than its not a bad choice. This is way more convenient than pneumatic air powered impact wrenches! Plus those 5 amp batteries are great for all day usage. This wrench gives a similar response to pneumatic air tool versions/air impact wrenches just without the air, of course.

This DeWalt impact wrench combines cordless and high torque, and this is a true competitor vs. the Milwaukee 2767.

Didn’t struggle with taking off any lug nuts, so no complaints. Suitable for installing lag bolts. It also comes with a DeWALT standard heavy-duty warranty. The power setting, when tightening bolts, the impact is a useful feature to have. This impact works beautifully for taking out anything really (except your wife maybe). Excellent product with considerable power to a snap-on 1/2 air impact gun.

The DCF899 really beats the air hose again for an impact wrench, this wrench is cordless and provides a high amount of torque. This impact is one of the best we’ve ever seen, takes nuts without any effort at all.

Porter Cable PCE211 1/2″ 7.5 Amp Impact Wrench

porter-cable-impact-wrench-300x300

Features a 7.5 Amp Motor, 450 ft-lbs of torque, 2200 rpm, 2700 bpm and a 1/2″ hog ring anvil for easy socket changes.

Worked pretty well to get nuts off quickly, but was struggling to get some of the more rusty lug nuts loose. So this wrench is not quite in the same range as the impact wrenches we reviewed above, but it’ll get the job done.

Will make your work quicker, that’s for sure. But we do not see it in the same range of power torque that you would get from an air impact wrench. Plus this drill is slightly heavier than other impact wrenches. It’s a corded tool, so it isn’t quite as convenient as the impacts we reviewed above, but for the price, it’s an excellent overall wrench.

Excellent for removing lug nuts off with some effort, so not the best pick, however, we got it for a great deal! This wrench is a bit on the heavy side, but it’ll get your regular nuts in a few seconds.

If you’re looking for something on the inexpensive side, then this is a good pick for best budget impact wrench.

Ingersoll Rand 2235 Ti Max 1/2″ Impact Wrench

Ingersoll Rand 2235 Ti Max 1/2″ Impact Wrench

This thing has impressive power. This really outdid any other air powered Ingersoll Rand impacts I reviewed. If you prefer air powered, then look no further than this impact gun. An excellent choice for mechanics. This is our choice for best air impact gun for the money.

It packs a punch, and we didn’t struggle with a single nut. Plus we dropped this thing a couple of times, and it didn’t break, so it’s pretty durable. A fantastic impact wrench, this Ingersoll Rand is a beast in the shop.

Has some real power and works fantastic taking off old wheel hub nuts with no effort, makes the job a lot easier. This is the best impact wrench for the money.

It feels lighter than their previous lines of impacts, but they haven’t sacrificed at all on the power. You will have fun using this impact gun every day. Takes bolts with no problem; this is the best impact gun for mechanics.

Excellent control and one of the strongest and reliable IR impacts out there. Any mechanic would be satisfied with this impact gun. We would recommend this any mechanic looking to replace their old impact from Ingersoll Rand.

Dewalt DCF890B Compact 3/8″ Impact Wrench

dcf890b-300x300

This thing is nowhere near the power of the ones listed about, but it’s still a decent impact wrench for mid torque jobs.

If you’re upgrading from a crappy wrench, you’ll probably feel the difference with this 3/8 impact. But really, I don’t think you’ll move more than 100 ft lbs with this wrench.

The DCF890 3/8″ Impact Wrench is compact and lightweight allowing the tool to be utilized in tight areas while the 3 LED lights provide visibility in low lit areas. Plus, it has a brushless motor for increase power, runtime and durability.

Source

It’ll do an ok job though, and the price is a bargain at the time of writing this. Another good bargain pick, so if the price is right, you can’t go wrong.

Makita XWT08Z 1/2 in Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless

xwt08z-300x300

Features 740 ft lbs of fastening torque and 1180 ft lbs of break-away torque. This Makita impact wrench really impressed us, even on its lowest torque setting the response was great. It is pretty big, but it works great. The issue with this drill is that it is big and more cumbersome than in comparison to others.

Worked like a champ to take lug nuts of one of our trucks. This thing packs a lot of power, and it makes it difficult not to overtighten nuts. The tool is huge and bulky, but the ergonomic rubber coating gives it a nice feel. It’s huge in comparison to other power wrenches in the shop though. Overall, despite its size, this wrench is another beast from Makita.

Built for auto use, it’s a high performing and durable wrench. Similar to other impact wrenches when comparing the battery life. Price to torque ratio is, and it gives good overall value.

Takes bolts off within seconds. Pretty happy with the 4 ah battery. Nice balance between power and battery too. Only issue is the size and weight, but if those aren’t important to you then it’s a decent choice.

Pneumatic vs Electric vs Cordless

Pneumatic Impact Wrenches

Pneumatic Impact Wrenches, or air impact wrenches, are typically used in professional rather than home environments. Especially popular with mechanics and automotive garages, air wrenches are fast and powerful. High-pressure air is required for working with these air impact guns get a good quality air compressor and lines that are 200+ psi for multiple impact sockets. Way less portable than their cordless counterparts. You can get a portable air compressor, but they are heavy, cumbersome & bulky. If you go for an air impact, it can get quite expensive. Usually not a good choice for home usage.

Electric Impact Wrenches

Electric Impact Wrenches, or corded impact wrenches, are not as durable as air impact wrenches. However, they are still fast and powerful. It’s great for home usage because it just requires a plug and a socket. The downside to electric is that it obviously has a cord, which can limit your mobility. They are easier to move around compared to pneumatic wrenches since you don’t need an air compressor.

Cordless Impact Wrenches

Cordless impact wrenches, or battery operated impact wrenches, are becoming more and more popular. As battery life improves and they are starting to offer more and more torque. The power of some cordless impact wrenches match or even exceed air powered and electric powered impact wrenches. It works well to get into those tight workspaces. The downside to cordless versions is that you must always remember to keep it charged. It also is heavier due to the battery. Compared to air impacts, cordless impacts are larger than pneumatic wrenches. The advantage of going cordless is that you have more mobility to move around. And, if you go on long road trips, it’s handy to keep one of these bad boys in the car.

Conclusion

There ya have it, this article was all about the best impact wrench. We went into the best models and brands in the market today and gave our reviews on all of them. If you have any questions, you can write to us below by leaving a comment.

Categories
Impact Wrench

Milwaukee 2767-20 Impact Wrench Review

Below you will find our review on the Milwaukee 2767-20 Impact Wrench.

Milwaukee 2767-20 High Torque ½” Impact Wrench Review

2767-245x300

Put away the air compressed tools and switch to the this powerful Battery Powered Impact Wrench from Milwaukee. This cordless impact wrench delivers 1000 ft-lbs of fastening torque and just over 1400 ft-lbs of nut-busting torque.

Pros:

  • Compact – measures only 8.39″ in length
  • 4 Mode Drive Control – Gives more control over fastening speed and torque
  • Anti Corrosion Casing – Case prevents damage from chemical corrosion

Cons:

  • Weight – heavy compared to other impact wrenches

In our opinion, this is a very good impact wrench. It gives enough power and is priced at an unbeatable value. The only disadvantage we could find was its weight, other than that, this cordless brushless Milwaukee impact driver, outperforms on pretty much every other aspect. We give it 5 stars. Want more impact driver reviews? Check out our article on the best impact wrench.